Twin Peaks Usenet Archive

Subject: Who did it
From: Jon.Webb@CS.CMU.EDU
Date: 1990-04-27, 10:57

I also think the murderer is Dr. Will Hayward, the doctor who delivered
Laura.  Someone else posted some reasons, and here's two more: when he
picked up his daughter Donna from the police station after James Hurley
was arrested, he seemed overly kind and forgiving in the car ("I
understand you were supposed to put some air in the tires").  I think
that following this conversation, while driving to pick up the bicycle,
he got Donna to tell him where she hid the necklace, which they went and
dug up together. (There's no way anyone could have found it just by
knowing the location unless they were there when James put the rock on
it; they would've had to be in the woods watching the two of them, and
it would be too malicious of Lynch to put the murderer just at the right
place in the woods at the right time.)  He then gave it to Dr. Jacoby,
the shrink, later -- who knows why.  This means Donna knows the necklace
is no longer buried.

This is better than `Clue'.

-- J