Twin Peaks Usenet Archive

Subject: Re: TP: some theories
From: horny@ucscl.UCSC.EDU (Michael Kaye)
Date: 1990-11-02, 10:42

In article <> (Emmanuel Goldstein) writes:
> >In article , (Robert Steven Glickstein) writes:
>> >> 
>> >> No, she was talking about Bobby Briggs.  See "The Secret Diary of
>> >> Laura Palmer."
>> >> 
> >While that may be true, there is a bit of an inconsistency between
> >the diary and the show. In the show, James told Donna that Laura
> >told him that Bobby told her that he had killed someone. (I'm
> >REALLY sorry for that last sentence but I couldn't think of any
> >other way to phrase that.) Anyway, in the diary, Laura was WITH
> >Bobby when he shot someone who was chasing them after a drug
> >deal gone sour. So it wouldn't be necessary for Bobby to
> >TELL her this. Unless he killed someone ELSE. Or unless
> >Laura keeps forgetting....

It doesn't seem inconsistant to me.  Laura just might not have felt 
like telling James that she was with Bobby when he killed someone.

Laura went out of her way to keep the dark side of her life out of 
view from people, James included.  If she had told him she was there,
he might have asked "what were you doing at a murder scene??", to 
which she might have answered, "oh, at the time I had just stolen 
a kilo of coke from these gangster types.  BOB tells me that Satan 
is saving a seat for me as a result of that night."  

Laura wasn't interested in this type of discussion with James.

Michael Kaye  "BOB needs a human hos...pitality girl"